1. Introduction
Australia has no national Bachelor of Nursing curriculum (Schwartz, 2019), and the mandated curricula inclusions are Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders’ health needs and a minimum of 800 hours of clinical placement (
). All Australian nursing curricula are accredited every three to 5 years by ANMAC, in line with the standards for nurses developed by the Nursing and Midwifery Board of Australia. Currently, there are no accepted gerontological competencies for Australian Bachelor of Nursing curricula (
Poulos et al., 2020- Poulos R.G.
- Boon M.Y.
- George A.
- Lui K.P.Y.
- Mak M.
- Maurice C.
- et al.
Preparing for an aging Australia: The development of multidisciplinary core competencies for the Australian health and aged care workforce.
), despite the projections of an increasing number of older people with chronic illnesses using health care services (
;
) and a shortage of nurses to provide care (
).
Graduate nurses need to be work-ready; they should have the appropriate skills, and knowledge, beyond technical competency, to adapt to the challenges of clinical workplaces (
Rogers et al., 2021- Rogers S.
- Redley B.
- Rawson H.
Developing work readiness in graduate nurses undertaking transition to practice programs: An integrative review.
). Nurses require specific knowledge and skills to care for older people with complex health care issues (
), and they must also be confident and capable of working with older people. However, over two decades of international literature suggests, that nurses are graduating with little preparation to work with older people (
Dahlke et al., 2021- Dahlke S.
- Kalogirou M.R.
- Swoboda N.L.
Registered nurses' reflections on their educational preparation to work with older people.
), particularly those with dementia (
Khait et al., 2022- Khait A.A.
- Menger A.
- Hamaideh S.H.
- Al-Modallal H.
- Abdalrahim A.
Nursing students’ knowledge about behavioral and biopsychosocial domains of dementia: A cross-sectional survey design.
). They also hold ageist views (
;
Koskinen et al., 2015- Koskinen S.
- Salminen L.
- Stolt M.
- Leino-Kilpi H.
The education received by nursing students regarding nursing older people: A scoping literature review.
); and do not consider a career working with older people to be satisfying or worthwhile (
Hunt et al., 2020- Hunt G.
- Verstappen A.
- Stewart L.
- Kool B.
- Slark J.
Career interest of undergraduate nursing students: A ten-year longitudinal study.
;
Hebditch et al., 2020- Hebditch M.
- Daley S.
- Wright J.
- Sherlock G.
- Scott J.
- Banerjee S.
Preferences of nursing and medical students for working with older adults and people with dementia: A systematic review.
).
An exploration of how care for the older person is taught in Australian nursing curricula, may provide some understanding of graduate nurses’ work readiness and career choices.
2. Literature review
The literature suggests that nursing students’ attitudes to caring for older people are negative (
Hunt et al., 2020- Hunt G.
- Verstappen A.
- Stewart L.
- Kool B.
- Slark J.
Career interest of undergraduate nursing students: A ten-year longitudinal study.
;
Liu et al., 2013- Liu Y.
- Norman I.J.
- While A.E.
Nurses’ attitudes towards older people: A systematic review.
) and that their career choices continue to reflect a preference for working in acute health care with younger people (
Hebditch et al., 2020- Hebditch M.
- Daley S.
- Wright J.
- Sherlock G.
- Scott J.
- Banerjee S.
Preferences of nursing and medical students for working with older adults and people with dementia: A systematic review.
).
Neville et al., 2014- Neville C.
- Dickie R.
- Goetz S.
What's stopping a career in gerontological nursing?.
found that undergraduate nursing students’ decisions not to work with older people was related to their educational experiences, in particular the curricula and experiences on clinical placements; the working conditions of specific health care settings, especially in residential aged care facilities (RACF); and ageism. Undergraduate nursing curricula remain acute-care focused with limited attention to chronic diseases, ageing and ageing-specific services (
Fetherstonhaugh et al., 2022- Fetherstonhaugh D.
- Rayner J.
- Solly K.
- Beattie E.
- Harrington A.
- Jeon Y-H.
- et al.
Teaching the care of older people in Australian nursing schools: Survey findings.
;
Calma et al., 2019- Calma K.R.B.
- Halcomb E.
- Stephens M.
The impact of curriculum on nursing students’ attitudes, perceptions and preparedness to work in primary health care: An integrative review.
). Content on the older person's care tends to be integrated (
Fetherstonhaugh et al., 2022- Fetherstonhaugh D.
- Rayner J.
- Solly K.
- Beattie E.
- Harrington A.
- Jeon Y-H.
- et al.
Teaching the care of older people in Australian nursing schools: Survey findings.
;
Garbrah et al., 2017- Garbrah W.
- Valimaki T.
- Palovaara M.
- Kankkunen P.
Nursing curriculums may hinder a career in gerontological nursing: An integrative review.
), and there are few nurse academics with expert gerontological knowledge to teach this content (
Fetherstonhaugh et al., 2022- Fetherstonhaugh D.
- Rayner J.
- Solly K.
- Beattie E.
- Harrington A.
- Jeon Y-H.
- et al.
Teaching the care of older people in Australian nursing schools: Survey findings.
;
Fulmer, 2020A retrospective/prospective on the future of geriatric nursing.
). Most Australian nursing students undertake their first clinical placement in a RACF (
Parker et al., 2021- Parker C.N.
- Harvey T.
- Johnston S.
- MacAndrew M.
An exploration of knowledge of students and staff at residential aged care facilities and implications for nursing education.
;
Rayner et al., 2022- Rayner J.
- Fetherstonhaugh D.
- Beattie E.
- Harrington A.
- Jeon Y-H.
- Moyle W.
- et al.
Australian nursing students’ clinical experiences in residential aged care: Reports from nurse academics.
). They commonly report these placement experiences in negative terms related to feeling unprepared (
Keeping-Burke et al., 2020- Keeping-Burke L.
- McCoskey R.
- Donovan C.
- Yetman L.
- Goudreau A.
Nursing students’ experiences with clinical placement in residential aged care facilities: A systematic review of qualitative evidence.
) and unsupported (
Forber et al., 2016- Forber J.
- DiGiacomo M.
- Carter B.
- Davidson P.
- Phillips J.
- Jackson D.
In pursuit of an optimal model of undergraduate nurse clinical education: An integrative review.
), having limited interaction with registered nurses (RNs) (
Hunt et al., 2020- Hunt G.
- Verstappen A.
- Stewart L.
- Kool B.
- Slark J.
Career interest of undergraduate nursing students: A ten-year longitudinal study.
), and poor working conditions in the sector (
Kydd et al., 2014- Kydd A.
- Engström G.
- Touhy T.A.
- Newman D.
- Skela-Savič B.
- Touzery S.H.
- et al.
Attitudes of nurses, and student nurses towards working with older people and to gerontological nursing as a career in Germany, Scotland, Slovenia, Sweden, Japan, and the United States.
). These negative clinical experiences can perpetuate nursing students’ ageism and influence their career choices (
Naughton et al., 2019- Naughton C.
- O'Shea K.L.
- Hayes N.
Incentivising a career in older adult nursing: The views of student nurses.
).
This paper reports findings associated with the challenges of teaching care of the older person content in Australian nursing curricula, and how pre-registration nursing students are prepared to care for older people, part of a larger study investigating care of older person content in nursing curricula.
4. Results
All 35 (100%) Australian SoN participated, including 33 universities, a Technical and Further Education (TAFE) organisation and an Institute of Advanced Education. Forty-five nurse academics, mainly women (n = 41, 91%) with at least one from each SoN, were interviewed. Most were co-ordinators of the undergraduate degree (n = 21, 60%).
The findings reported here are from an analysis of two open-ended questions: what are the challenges of teaching older person's care in Australian undergraduate nursing curricula? Furthermore, how pre-registration nurses are prepared to care for older people? The analysis produced two discrete themes – the curriculum and the ageist attitudes of students and nurse academics.
4.1 The curriculum
Respondents spoke at length about why they could not include more content on older person's care in their curriculum. The discussion focused on where and when to include this content as the curricula are already full, leaving very little time to include additional content.When we look at everything that must be in the curriculum, and everyone wants a fast-tracked pathway. There is just not enough time to get nurses on graduation to be workforce ready (SoN 28).
We have to have governance, we have got to have risk management, quality and safety, patient safety, all of the standards that need to be addressed now in an undergraduate curriculum make it very packed (SoN 6).
It's what we are required to have - we must have a mental health unit, an Indigenous unit, an evidence-based/research unit. There is so much required in the curriculum. (SoN 1).
Some respondents, acknowledging that there was insufficient content on older person care despite nurses being most likely to care for older people in all health care settings, reported that their current curriculum was poorly designed. The curricula were criticised for being acute care focused. The content on older person's care emphasised bodily care, with little content on healthy ageing, older peoples’ specific needs or communication with people with dementia. In addition, respondents noted that clinical experiences associated with older people were generally undertaken in RACFs in the first year of the degree, which further reinforced students’ perceptions of the care of older people.We've got serious problems about how we conceptualise older person care in the curriculum. We consistently conceptualise clinical placements about older people as aged care facility placements, ignoring the fact that older people are in every area of health service (SoN 2).
We are very much into the pathology behind ageing as opposed to the human side, which impacts the quality of care provided (SoN 31).
The lack of time to teach the care of the older person content, despite acknowledging the need and value of this for nursing students, prompted some respondents to suggest the Bachelor of Nursing should be extended to a four-year degree, with curriculum renewal focusing on the care of the older person in line with national health care priorities.We need more time to do this teaching. I would definitely be an advocate for the four-year degree because there actually isn't enough time. I don't think you can take out what we've currently got, but it would be great if we had more time to really go into the physiology of ageing and to bring it back in the later years. It's fine to introduce it in first year, but you introduce a whole lot of foundation concepts that can't be built, there's not time to build on all of them (SoN 30).
Others spoke about the difficulties in (re)designing a curriculum while adhering to the ANMAC standards. They felt this made it very difficult to introduce new content or expand on existing areas. Some thought ANMAC should provide guidance to SoN.If there was some guidance around what needs to be incorporated in undergraduate curriculum, that would be helpful. When you're trying to put a curriculum together, trying to think of everything is difficult (SoN 13).
Participants supported standalone gerontological subjects in nursing curricula and acknowledgement that gerontological nursing needed to be genuinely promoted as a legitimate career path.Universities are too quick to incorporate older person care into the entire curriculum. I think that the standalone subject is really necessary for the student's better understanding of older person care. They're the largest population (SoN 5).
I think [gerontological nursing] needs to be promoted to undergraduate as a legitimate career because they gravitate towards health care that is more acute, and they look for graduate programs within those. I think we need to encourage them. It is a legitimate, challenging career pathway (SoN 15).
Within the curriculum theme, nurse academics reported that scheduling clinical experiences in RACF for first year students was a challenge.The biggest challenge is sending out first year nurses into aged care placements because of who they're buddied up with - carers (SoN 30).
Many respondents felt that RACF settings were unsuitable for first-year students due to the complex nature of the care required by residents, especially those with dementia, and because there were insufficient numbers of RNs available to supervise students. In addition, respondents felt these experiences reinforced students' existing ageist views and negatively influenced their attitudes toward pursuing a gerontological career.
4.2 The ageist attitudes of students and nurse academics
The second challenge to teaching care of the older person in Australian undergraduate degrees was the ageist attitudes of students and nurse academics. Respondents spoke at length about the stereotypical attitudes about older people held by nursing students. Some added that this was more evident among graduate-entry students who currently or previously worked in RACFs. Respondents reported that ageist attitudes influenced students’ engagement with older person care content and their clinical experiences with older people. However, they acknowledged that it was difficult to counter these attitudes, which reflective the wider society.I think one of the challenges is that ageism does exist, and you've got to really challenge that with students (SoN 27)
It is ageism. Some students email me about it ‘It's my third time to go to aged care facilities or look after someone who's older, I think it is enough’ (SoN 4).
Further, respondents stated that some nurse academics also held negative attitudes and biases about nursing older people or preferred acute care nursing over gerontological nursing. The ageist attitudes of academics can influence students’ pre-existing ageist views, a challenge acknowledged by respondents to teaching content on older person care.We have many staff who worked in aged care or did placements themselves. That experience of aged care is predominantly their memory, and sometimes they can be quite negative (SoN 22).
Our biggest challenge is attitudes. I don't necessarily mean attitudes of the students. It's more the attitudes of the people teaching them (SoN 34).
Finding the right clinical teacher who isn't someone who just dismisses aged care and already has those negative views. I think staff do hold ageist views (SoN 16).
Coupled with ageist attitudes, respondents reported that students had unrealistic ideas about nursing and who they would be caring for. According to respondents, popular culture, particularly social media and television, significantly influenced whom students imagined they would be nursing and in what health care settings. At odds with the reality of health care settings and patient cohorts, television programs depicted nurses caring for young, acutely ill people in highly technical settings such as intensive care units (ICU) or emergency departments (ED). Respondents reported that popular culture was often the driver for some students to start a nursing degree and that it was difficult to counter these perceptions, especially in the first year.We're battling against the differing motivations to doing nursing now. It's about fighting against their preconceived ideas about what nursing is, and television is killing us (SoN 23).
It's the perceptions that students have, how they view nursing. They want to perform venepuncture and all the things they see on TV that have formed their image of nursing (SoN 15).
Others spoke about how students conflate care of the older person with care of people living in RACFs; and of the impact of the negative media coverage about RACFs, especially that related to the coverage of the Australian Royal Commission into Quality and Safety in Aged Care, which intensified student's negative views of the care of older people.The majority of people that students will care for are over 65, regardless of where they work. I don't think students realise that. Even when I've said that you get this surprised look on students’ faces, and you think, “I don't know who you're thinking you're going to be caring for”. It's going to be a very long battle because, unfortunately, even in the media, there's never a nice light shone on aged care (SoN 16).
When asked about how their SoN advertised their Bachelor of Nursing degree, many added that their websites perpetuated the inaccurate image of nursing and patient cohorts, as very few websites included older people as recipients of care.Most of our websites tend to be lovely young people with stethoscopes and white coats in labs, which drives us crazy because that doesn't really describe nursing (SoN 34).
On the website, when you see it, it's really the students that are the focus. I mean there is one image of a person who's in bed, and the person is very young, and it's a nice pretty patient (SoN 17).
As a result of these widely accepted yet often inaccurate images of nursing, health care settings and patient cohorts, participants reported that student nurses preferred and valued the acute care content over other areas, especially content on older person's care. They added that students also sought acute care areas for their graduate positions.They [students] gravitate towards acute health care facilities, and they look for graduate programs in those (SoN 15).
Our biggest challenge is that students see care of the older person as in residential care. Not understanding the complexities of chronic and acute health changes. I think that is associated with the ageist view (SoN 17).
Normally they all want to go and work in ED, or ICU, or midwifery (SoN 35).
All respondents spoke about the limited number of nurse academics in their school with gerontological qualifications, expertise and experience to teach the content on older person's care adequately (
Fetherstonhaugh et al., 2022- Fetherstonhaugh D.
- Rayner J.
- Solly K.
- Beattie E.
- Harrington A.
- Jeon Y-H.
- et al.
Teaching the care of older people in Australian nursing schools: Survey findings.
). This lack of expertise also extended to clinical teachers. In addition, respondents acknowledged that older person care was now more complex than previously understood, which was lost on students and some nurse academics. This added to the challenge of finding academics who could teach the content effectively and authoritatively.
One of the challenges is the lack of [academic staff] experience or expertise or being too specialist in another field and getting across to the students the importance of, and differences in, caring for the aged across a variety of settings and the complexities that this entails (SoN 3).
I think one of the challenges is that some academics sometimes have a bit of a blind spot to older people. They want to just give the acute medical ICU type sessions, and they want that biological, biomedical type curriculum to be at the forefront of the nurse, and that's not the reality of what students are going to be seeing now or into the future (SoN 13).
5. Discussion
The changing dynamics of the Australian health care sectors, including the ageing of the population, the increased complexity of care, innovations in health care technologies and restrained spending (
Calder et al., 2019- Calder R.
- Dunkin R.
- Rochford C.
- Nichols T.
Australian health services: Too complex to navigate. A review of the national reviews of Australia’s health service arrangements.
), means nursing graduates need to be work-ready. However, the literature suggests that the current preparation of nurses is inadequate, and graduate nurses are not ‘work-ready’ (
Missen et al., 2015- Missen K.
- McKenna L.
- Beauchamp A.
Work readiness of nursing graduates: Current perspectives of graduate nurse program coordinators.
). In particular, they are insufficiently prepared to care for older people (
Fetherstonhaugh et al., 2022- Fetherstonhaugh D.
- Rayner J.
- Solly K.
- Beattie E.
- Harrington A.
- Jeon Y-H.
- et al.
Teaching the care of older people in Australian nursing schools: Survey findings.
), a population cohort they will increasingly encounter in all health care settings.
These findings highlight the challenges in teaching content on older person's care in Australian undergraduate nursing degrees, which may impact student nurses’ career choices, as has been found elsewhere (
Hunt et al., 2020- Hunt G.
- Verstappen A.
- Stewart L.
- Kool B.
- Slark J.
Career interest of undergraduate nursing students: A ten-year longitudinal study.
). Career choices are often made as an undergraduate, with many factors influencing the decision, including the factors identified in this research. While there was consensus concerning the importance of teaching care of the older person in all SoN, there was little indication of a systematic approach to delivering this content because of the challenges reported.
As this study found, international reviews suggest that nursing curricula are overcrowded (
Deschodt et al., 2010- Deschodt M.
- Dierckx de casterle B.
- Milisen K.
Gerontological care in nursing education programmes.
), and nurse academics admit that they have no time to comprehensively cover content on older person's care (
Dahlke et al., 2020- Dahlke S.
- Davidson S.
- Kalogirou M.R.
- et al.
Nursing faculty and students’ perspectives of how students learn to work with older people.
). Content on older person's care in Australian undergraduate nursing programs is generally delivered as a combination of standalone subjects and integrated across the curricula, with a small number of SoN reporting the content is included in electives (
Fetherstonhaugh et al., 2022- Fetherstonhaugh D.
- Rayner J.
- Solly K.
- Beattie E.
- Harrington A.
- Jeon Y-H.
- et al.
Teaching the care of older people in Australian nursing schools: Survey findings.
). Offering content on older person's care as an elective subject may not provide the attention it deserves. It has been suggested that electives attract fewer students (
Grocki and Bert Fox, 2004- Grocki J.H.
- Bert Fox G.E.
Gerontological coursework in undergraduate nursing programs in the United States: A regional study.
) especially if the subject matter does not align with their career goals (
Babad, 2001Student course selection: Differential consideration for first and last course.
). More than 20 years ago,
Nay et al., 1999- Nay R.
- Garratt S.
- Koch S.
Challenges for Australian nursing in the International Year of Older Persons.
argued that the integration of content on older person's care devalues it; however, more research is required as there is a lack of evidence of the effectiveness of offering standalone subjects over embedding or integrating content on older person's care across the curriculum. Some respondents suggested that a four-year degree was required as current curricula are ‘full’ reiterating Recommendation 12 (exploring ways to extend the current three-year degree) from the recent review of nursing education in Australia (
Schwartz, 2019Educating the Nurse of the Future—Report of the Independent Review into Nursing Education.
, p. xv). This would also bring the degree in line with nursing degrees in Canada, Ireland, the United States, and many European countries.
The acute care focus of nursing curricula in Australia (
Fetherstonhaugh et al., 2022- Fetherstonhaugh D.
- Rayner J.
- Solly K.
- Beattie E.
- Harrington A.
- Jeon Y-H.
- et al.
Teaching the care of older people in Australian nursing schools: Survey findings.
0 and elsewhere (
Garbrah et al., 2017- Garbrah W.
- Valimaki T.
- Palovaara M.
- Kankkunen P.
Nursing curriculums may hinder a career in gerontological nursing: An integrative review.
) also influences nursing students’ career choices. Students value nursing that involves more technical skills, so their career preferences are for highly technical health care settings such as emergency departments (EDs) and intensive care units (ICUs) (
Neville et al., 2014- Neville C.
- Dickie R.
- Goetz S.
What's stopping a career in gerontological nursing?.
). Academics in this study reported that students come into nursing with an expectation and desire to work in technical areas of health care which may reflect their exposure to images of nurses in popular culture and inherent ageism. Ageism is ‘pervasive, widely accepted, and normative in many societies and is a form of prejudice that goes unchallenged’ (
, p. 5). Ageist attitudes are most common among younger people (
), including among student nurses internationally (
;
Koskinen et al., 2015- Koskinen S.
- Salminen L.
- Stolt M.
- Leino-Kilpi H.
The education received by nursing students regarding nursing older people: A scoping literature review.
;
Kydd et al., 2014- Kydd A.
- Engström G.
- Touhy T.A.
- Newman D.
- Skela-Savič B.
- Touzery S.H.
- et al.
Attitudes of nurses, and student nurses towards working with older people and to gerontological nursing as a career in Germany, Scotland, Slovenia, Sweden, Japan, and the United States.
) and in Australia (
Frost et al., 2016- Frost J.
- Ranse K.
- Grealish L.
Brief report assessing ageist behaviours in undergraduate nursing students using the Relating to Older People Evaluation (ROPE) survey.
;
McKenzie and Brown, 2014Nursing students’ intentions to work in dementia care: Influence of age, ageism, and perceived barriers.
).
Neville et al., 2014- Neville C.
- Dickie R.
- Goetz S.
What's stopping a career in gerontological nursing?.
argue that this valuing of technical health care reflects the pervasive ageism inherent in societies.
Attitudes to nursing older people are reinforced by popular culture, particularly portrayals of nurses working and the people they are nursing, which is commonly set in highly technical acute care settings with younger people (
van Iersel et al., 2016- van Iersel M.
- Latour C.H.
- de Vos R.
- Kirschner P.A.
- Scholte op Reimer W.J.
Nursing students' perceptions of community care and other areas of nursing practice – A review of the literature.
). These portrayals influence understandings of nursing in particular contexts and in turn, students career choices (
;
Terry and Peck, 2020Television as a career motivator and education tool: A final-year nursing student cohort study.
) because nursing students start their degree with a ‘predominantly lay-informed conceptualisation of nursing’ (
McCann et al., 2010- McCann T.V.
- Clark E.
- Lu S.
Bachelor of nursing students career choices: A three-year longitudinal study.
, p. 34), reinforced through popular culture. (
Terry and Peck, 2020Television as a career motivator and education tool: A final-year nursing student cohort study.
) found that medical television programs such as
Grey's Anatomy and
Offspring were strong motivators for close to a third of students to commence a nursing degree (p.354).
Ageist attitudes held by nursing students not only influence their career choice but may affect their behaviour toward the care of older people, so identification of negative attitudes towards older people should be a concern for nurse academics (
). However, as this study found, nursing academics and clinical supervisors have also been found to have negative attitudes toward the care of older people, which reinforce and support students’ ageist attitudes (
Garbrah et al., 2020- Garbrah W.
- Kankkunen P.
- Valimaki T.
Gerontological nurse teachers' abilities and influence on students' willingness in older people nursing: A cross-sectional, correlational survey.
;
Simpkins-Gibbs and Kulig, 2017- Simpkins-Gibbs S.
- Kulig J.C.
“We definitely are role models”: Exploring how clinical instructors influence nursing students, attitudes towards older adults.
). The literature highlights the importance of having positive role models and enthusiastic academic teaching staff with sufficient knowledge and experience in older person care. Further, gerontological nursing education has been shown to foster the development of positive attitudes towards nursing older people (
Hovey et al., 2017- Hovey S.
- Dyck M.
- Reese C.
- Kim M.
Nursing students' attitudes toward persons who are aged: An integrative review.
). To moderate the effects of inaccurate portrayals of nursing, academics, and accrediting and professional bodies must actively work to promote what nursing involves. SoN can address this issue by including images of nurses working with older people on their websites advertising the Bachelor of Nursing programs, which are currently missing.
Australian nurses will encounter older people in acute care settings, community care, home care, and residential aged care. Recognition of the importance of gerontological competencies and incorporating care of the older person content into educational programs for health care professionals, including nurses, has been a major priority for the Hartford Consortium in the United States for the last thirty years (
). In Australia, competency in gerontological nursing is required now in all health care settings and is going to become even more essential as the Australian population ages (
). As Australian undergraduate nursing programs undergo curricula review and revision, SoN need to consider a more comprehensive approach to including gerontological content to prepare work-ready graduates.
Article info
Publication history
Published online: September 13, 2022
Accepted:
August 25,
2022
Received in revised form:
July 6,
2022
Received:
May 18,
2022
Copyright
© 2022 Australian College of Nursing Ltd. Published by Elsevier Ltd.